Current Issues graphic


Confronting Terrorist Threats:

THE CROWE
COMMISSION REPORT



Read about the Briefing


 

Rescue workers carry a woman over the rubble of a building destroyed during the terrorist bombing at the U.S. Embassy in Nairobi, Kenya in August 1998. (AP/Wide World)


The "Report of the Accountability Review Boards on the Embassy Bombings in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam on August 7, 1998" was released by the U.S. Department of State in January 1999. This Current Issues Briefing was a forum to discuss its findings.


Admiral Crowe

Admiral William J. Crowe

USIP President Richard Solomon moderated the briefing, which featured a presentation by retired Admiral William J. Crowe, Jr., Chairman of the Accountability Review Boards investigating the August 7, 1998 bombings of U.S. embassies in Nairobi, Kenya, and Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania. (report)

In his remarks, Admiral Crowe cited the challenges brought by the rise of transnational terrorist syndicates, as well as the failure of several Administrations and Congresses to adequately fund improvements to protect the physical security of U.S. diplomatic missions abroad. "Security must be given a higher priority by all those involved in order to prevent disasters in the future," Admiral Crowe said. "As we say in the Navy, it's an all-hands proposition."

Moreover, Crowe, a former Chairman of the Joint Chief of Staff, repeated his defense of the Review Boards' recommendation to spend some $14 billion over the next decade to enhance the safety of all Embassies and other overseas installations. "We were told that this would be a dead issue in six months," Crowe said, commenting on anticipated congressional resistance to the cost of security reforms. "It's a shame to have the budget controlling lives."

Ambassador Philip C. Wilcox, Jr., former Coordinator for Counter-Terrorism at the State Department and a member of one of the Accountability Boards, noted that there have been more than 200 attacks on U.S. missions and diplomatic personnel in the past 12 years. Against this backdrop, the embassy bombings were a surprise. "We've had experience with such attacks," he said, "but our memories were short. The gravity of these attacks has prompted a strong sense in the Department of State to do more to protect Americans serving their country abroad."

"We've lost more Ambassadors since World War Two than we have Admirals and Generals," Admiral Crowe added, stressing the impact of the terrorist threat on U.S. officials overseas.

Other panel members included international security consultant and renown terrorism expert Brian Jenkins and Gideon Rose, the Olin Fellow in National Security at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York.

Jenkins noted that the threat posed to American installations abroad by truck bombs was understood 14 years ago, when a similar Commission led by Admiral Bobby Inman investigated the embassy bombings in Beirut and Kuwait. "It was unimaginable to see that 14 years later our security plans did not address transnational terrorism or the threat posed by large vehicular bombs,"Jenkins said. He noted that while the volume of international terrorism has decreased in recent years, the frequency and scope of such attacks remained a serious source of concern. "If the future is not worst than the past," he argued, "we should expect an attack on a U.S. diplomatic facility every four years."

Citing a recently released report by the Department of State on reforms adopted following the bombings, Gideon Rose noted that the terrorism in its modern form is not unlike that faced during the past century. The tragedy of the African embassy bombings would only be compounded "if other aspects of our foreign policy were gutted, resulting in a retrenchment of U.S. activity and influence abroad."

Rose also addressed the effectiveness of U.S. military retaliation in the aftermath of the embassy bombings. "The U.S. response to terrorism must be seen as a just response," Rose argued. "In Sudan, our action was not as clear as we hoped it would be. Ultimately, we hurt ourselves and our credibility."

 


The presentations were followed by questions from the floor.

 


For more information on this Current Issues Briefing, or the Institute's work on political violence and terrorism, please contact Dr. Patrick Cronin, Director of Research and Studies, which co-sponsored the briefing with the help of the Institute's Office of Communications.

 


Media Inquiries should be directed to the Office of Communications by phone at 202.429.3828 or e-mail at usip_requests@usip.org.

Latest Publications

In Europe, Xi Looks to Boost Ties — and Sow Divisions

In Europe, Xi Looks to Boost Ties — and Sow Divisions

Thursday, May 16, 2024

Chinese leader Xi Jinping last week made his first trip to the European continent in five years, visiting France, Hungary and Serbia. In Paris, Xi faced tough questions over trade and China’s support for Russia and its war in Ukraine, but met a much friendlier reception in Budapest and Belgrade, both of which view China as a key economic and political partner. Still, the visit demonstrated the obstacles Beijing faces in fostering deeper ties across Europe, where resentment is simmering over China’s moral and materiel aid to Russia and what Europe views as unfair trade practices.

Type: Question and Answer

Global Policy

Traumatic Decarbonization in Fragile States

Traumatic Decarbonization in Fragile States

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

The process of decarbonization—that is, the replacement of fossil fuels with non-hydrocarbon-based forms of energy—is essential for meeting the climate goals articulated by international agreements. But in fragile, oil-dependent nations, where hydrocarbon revenues are often a key means of political control, decarbonization can spell the difference between peace and conflict. This report examines the consequences of the sudden loss of oil revenues for fragile, conflict-affected states and provides recommendations for policymakers on how to manage future decarbonization peacefully.

Type: Peaceworks

Conflict Analysis & PreventionEconomicsEnvironmentFragility & Resilience

China’s Edge in the Pacific Islands: Xi Jinping Makes Time for Leaders

China’s Edge in the Pacific Islands: Xi Jinping Makes Time for Leaders

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

If the U.S. government wants an edge over China in the Pacific Islands, it needs to facilitate more meetings between the president of the United States and regional leaders, preferably one-on-one. When Pacific Island leaders fly to Beijing, they often have a one-on-one meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, but such a meeting between the leader of a Pacific Island country and a sitting president of the United States has never taken place. The White House has only conducted joint meetings with Pacific Island leaders. Sometimes even joint meetings don’t make the cut.

Type: Analysis

Global Policy

At the Sahel’s Center, Tension Rises Over Chad’s Disputed Election

At the Sahel’s Center, Tension Rises Over Chad’s Disputed Election

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

A disputed presidential election in Chad last week is making few global headlines, but poses new risks to African and international efforts to reverse the Sahel region’s spreading instability, conflict and human displacement. Chad is centered in the world’s largest belt of military rule: six nations across Africa that have suffered armed coups since 2020. Among them, Chad is the first to hold elections to restore civilian rule. But a string of setbacks to a fully credible vote has yielded a contested result that risks further domestic conflict and a narrowing of popular legitimacy for the next government, led by the incumbent transitional president, Mahamat Idriss Deby.

Type: Analysis

Global Elections & Conflict

View All Publications