With the Obama administration poised to transition the bulk of its forces out of Afghanistan by 2014, it’s all the more critical to build credible, accountable and enduring institutions there.

August 19, 2011

With the Obama administration poised to transition the bulk of its forces out of Afghanistan by 2014, it’s all the more critical to build credible, accountable and enduring institutions there.

And it takes the so-called whole-of-government approach , fusing all relevant agencies and institutions to achieve a singular goal, and build that kind of capacity in time, say American defense and other officials. The U.S. Defense Department’s Ministry of Defense Adviser, or MoDA, program, marries American institutional expertise with counterparts in Afghanistan’s fledgling ministries to help them to become viable for the day when the U.S. and its international partners leave.

Lt. Gen. William Caldwell, who heads NATO’s training effort in Afghanistan, calls the MoDA program “one of the most important contributors” to the achievements made within the Afghan government thus far.

“The MoDA program has been the key enabler for us to not only achieve progress in the training mission, but literally it has been an absolute game changer,” he said during a taped appearance at an August 11 event at the United States Institute of Peace (USIP) to welcome home advisers. The program relies on individuals within the Defense Department with relevant professional experience to advise, mentor, train and teach their Afghan counterparts. As proof of its value, Gen. David Petraeus, then the top commander in Afghanistan, requested 100 more advisers after observing the positive impact the first team of 17 advisers had had. Currently there are about 47 advisers serving in Afghanistan.

Michael Lumpkin, the principal deputy assistant secretary for Special Operations/Low Intensity Conflict, who also spoke at the event at USIP, related several anecdotes about how individual advisers were making a difference.

“All of these successes – and countless others – rely on the strong trust-based relationships built between each MoDA adviser and his or her counterpart,” Lumpkin said. “Each achievement – even the smallest one – is a testament to the quality of the program’s pre-deployment training which emphasizes developing sustainable and locally-powered solutions through respect, humility and empathy,” he said.

USIP plays a big part in that training, conducting two weeks of classroom training of the seven-week program for advisers before they deploy to Afghanistan. USIP will do its fourth iteration of the training in the fall of 2011, and more next year.

David Clifton is a retired Marine colonel who as a civilian recently returned from a 14-month deployment as adviser to the Afghan Ministry of Interior’s chief of staff. He said one of the things that he noticed was the passion his American colleagues had for helping build Afghanistan. “I was used to that in the Marines, but it just struck me that we had this civilian reservoir of commitment, and they are making a difference,” he said. MoDA advisers work each day to help Afghanistan achieve a level of competence that will serve the Afgan government when the U.S. and other countries ultimately leave. The goal is to be “Afghan good enough” - a practical approach to doing just enough to make it work, Clifton explained. He believes the MoDA program will become the focus of the U.S.-led effort in Afghanistan as “transition” becomes the new buzzword.

“I think the ministry adviser program over the next few years is the center of gravity,” he said.

Another MoDA adviser, Char Rusnak, a Navy rocket scientist who now works within the Afghan National Security Forces’ gender integration effort, wrote an e-mail to the program’s leaders commending the program that there are good days and there are bad. In the end, wrote Rusnak, the advisers are making a difference.

“Although some days here are long, tiring or discouraging, others are equally uplifting, exhilarating and encouraging,” Rusnak wrote in the e-mail read aloud by Lumpkin.

While Lumpkin lamented the fact that a program such as MoDA wasn’t stood up earlier, he’d like to see the capability “institutionalized” so the U.S. government can call it up the next time it needs to advise and mentor civilians overseas.He noted that programs like USIP’s MoDA training is vital because it helps other countries ultimately do for themselves. And, it’s a big bang for a small buck.

“Strengthening foreign defense institutions is an increasingly critical element of our overseas engagement, and through inexpensive programs like MoDA, we can help partners build effective, accountable and well-governed defense ministries,” he said.

He added that in the end, the benefits to American civilians “may prove greater” than the Afghan partners they deploy to advise. “When MoDA program advisers return to their Department of Defense positions here in the United States, they bring back a wealth of new skills, knowledge and experiences.”

Nadia Gerspacher, a USIP program officer who runs the MoDA program for the Institute, said one of the values of the training program is that it helps advisers to make “informed decisions in a reform environment.” Relationships are key, and picking the right kind of adviser to deploy overseas is important if that relationship is to work. “Building a rapport is all important in advising and that is directly impacted by the type of person that has been selected, the preparation they received and the conditions in which they are asked to operate,” Gerspacher said.National Defense University President Vice Admiral Ann Rondeau, a USIP board member, said working with the whole-of-government to provide the best mentoring in Afghanistan is critical to creating positive perceptions of Americans in Afghanistan. The MoDA program, she said, helps cement that critical relationship.

“It matters that we are trusted, it matters that we listen, it matters that we’re willing to contribute and to be part of a team that makes things happen,” she said.

Explore Further

Related Publications

Kabul School Bombing Reinforces Fears Over Post-Withdrawal Security

Kabul School Bombing Reinforces Fears Over Post-Withdrawal Security

Thursday, May 20, 2021

By: Belquis Ahmadi; Fatema Ahmadi

For the Dasht-e-Barchi neighborhood of Kabul, home to the Hazara minority group, the devastating May 8 bombing outside a school is part of a disturbing trend of attacks in the area. The bombing killed at least 85 and injured around 150 — mostly young girls — and coincided with concerns of escalating violence as the United States withdraws combat troops from Afghanistan. Although no group has claimed responsibility, the Islamic State group (ISIS) has perpetrated similar attacks in the past and many suspect it was again responsible. 

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Conflict Analysis & Prevention; Peace Processes

Even After Withdrawal, U.S. Retains Leverage Over Taliban

Even After Withdrawal, U.S. Retains Leverage Over Taliban

Thursday, April 29, 2021

By: Karen Decker

President Biden’s announcement that U.S. troops would withdraw by September 11 has many Afghans and observers warning of a quick collapse of the Afghan state and a new phase in the country’s civil war. Without minimizing the challenges ahead, the United States should avoid any self-fulfilling prophecy of imminent collapse by insisting that the only future for Afghanistan is one that advances the gains of the past 20 years. As troops begin to depart, it is an opportune time to examine three forms of leverage the United States has to promote a political settlement.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Peace Processes

Democracy Is the Afghan Government’s Best Defense Against the Taliban

Democracy Is the Afghan Government’s Best Defense Against the Taliban

Thursday, April 22, 2021

By: Scott Worden; Belquis Ahmadi

The Biden administration’s announcement last week that U.S. troops would be out of Afghanistan by September 11 came as a blow to the current peace talks and many Afghan citizens who appreciate the rights and freedoms that international forces have helped to defend against the Taliban. Still, President Biden made clear that the United States continues to support the Afghan government and democratic system, and, to that end, the administration has indicated it would request $300 million from Congress in additional civilian aid. But Biden explicitly de-linked U.S. troops from that equation — stating that they would not be “a bargaining chip between warring parties.”

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Peace Processes; Gender; Democracy & Governance

View All Publications