Worldwide deaths from terrorist incidents jumped 80 percent in 2014 compared with the year before and were concentrated in five major conflict zones, according to the third annual Global Terrorism Index, released November 17. While that conclusion was unsurprising, the index included less obvious findings with implications for policy makers who have to tailor solutions to specific countries and regions, according to experts who discussed the study at the U.S. Institute of Peace.

Buses parked near a terminal in central Baghdad were destroyed by two car bombs at 7:50 a.m. August 17, 2005.
Photo Courtesy of the U.S. Army

Data in the index help differentiate between causes of terrorist incidents within countries and those that are transnational, said Georgia Holmer, director of countering violent extremism at USIP.

“Violent extremists have [harnessed] their agenda to already existing [conflict] dynamics and profound structural challenges,” Holmer said. “It’s important that we separate out the problem set of what happens in Iraq and Nigeria from what happens in Paris and London and the threats that face us domestically. Not only are the problems different but solutions are different.”

“Good data can be used to help us make sense of complex problems and counter unfounded conventional wisdoms.”   –Michael Jensen, data collection manager for the Global Terrorism Database.

Of the 32,658 terrorism-related deaths in 2014, 78 percent occurred in Nigeria, Syria, Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan, according to the index. The Australia-based Institute for Economics and Peace produces the index, using data from the Global Terrorism Database, a U.S. government-backed project based at the University of Maryland.

The rise in fatalities is the largest in 15 years, according to the index and an accompanying report released just days after the Islamic State, or ISIS, killed 172 people with its attacks in Paris and Beirut. While ISIS extremists have dominated headlines in the past year, killing 6,073 people in 2014, the Nigerian group Boko Haram was even deadlier, the report said. Boko Haram’s attacks killed 6,644 people, 77 percent of them private citizens.

The index and report, which studied 162 countries, put the problem of terrorism into context in other ways. It estimated global economic damage from terrorism at about $53 billion last year, a ten-fold increase since 2000.  It found that worldwide deaths from terrorist attacks in 2014 were far outnumbered by an estimated 437,000 homicides.

Data Can Help Policy

These data can help policy makers improve their decision-making capabilities, the experts said at USIP. The findings on Boko Haram could help policy makers in Africa take steps to protect their citizens, panelists said. And data on the lone-wolf attacks that dominate in the West could show what helps law enforcement agencies stop such attacks.

Having good data on terrorist incidents also helps in formulating policy when multiple international partners are involved, Erdberg said.

Good data can help “confront counterproductive behavior,” she said. Sometimes “it’s uncomfortable to talk in the policy realm about what doesn’t work, especially with international partners.” But when there’s data, even if it’s not entirely foolproof, “it’s able to change the conversation a little bit more than what it would be otherwise from a values perspective, so data has incredibly important role.”

The Global Terrorism Database compiles details on 140,000 terrorist attacks around the globe. Researchers work from open sources, collecting as many as 2 million news reports daily and distilling them to about 25,000 articles that are manually read every month.

The Global Terrorism Index found that political violence committed by the state and the presence of a broader armed conflict were factors closely correlated with terrorist violence. About 92 percent of terrorist attacks over the past 25 years occurred in countries where political violence was backed by the state, the study found.

Countering 'Unfounded' Conventions

In the richer countries that are part of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, socio-economic factors like youth unemployment, belief in democracy, drug crime and attitudes toward immigration were more strongly correlated with terrorism, leading to more so-called lone-wolf attacks, the study said.

In other countries, corruption and a weak business environment were correlated with terrorism, it said.

Better information helps change entrenched narratives about what works in combating terrorism, said Michael Jensen, data collection manager for the Global Terrorism Database.

“Data can be an important component in our conversations about violent extremism and how to counter it,” Jensen said. “Good data can be used to help us make sense of complex problems and counter unfounded conventional wisdoms and improve our responses to difficult challenges.”

That is also the goal behind USIP’s recent effort with the State Department and the U.S. Agency for International Development in launching a collaborative research program called Researching Solutions to Violent Extremism or RESOLVE. The goal is to bring together individuals and research organizations from around the world, including those focused on local extremist groups, to draw broader lessons for policy makers.

The project aims to understand violent extremism at the community level as well as the role of the state in its relationship with such communities, said Andrew Blum, vice president of planning, learning and evaluation at USIP.

While policy making “is never going to be purely data driven…the better the data, the more seriously it’s likely to be taken,” and the more it can help counter conventional wisdom, Erdberg said.

Related Publications

Nigeria's Security Failures: The Link Between EndSARS and Boko Haram

Nigeria's Security Failures: The Link Between EndSARS and Boko Haram

Thursday, December 17, 2020

By: Aly Verjee; Chris Kwaja

At first glance, the October state-led killings of protesters in Nigeria’s largest city, Lagos, seem to have little in common with the November Boko Haram massacre of at least 43 farmers in Nigeria’s northeast, or the December 11 abduction of hundreds of school students in Katsina State. With vastly different circumstances, motivations, and perpetrators—and separated by hundreds of miles—all three episodes could easily be recorded as just further tragic installments in Nigeria’s long history of violence. However, these incidents underscore the wider failure of the state to provide security for its citizens, only deepening the trust deficit felt by Nigerians.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Violent Extremism; Fragility & Resilience

When the World Moves On: What’s Next for Nigeria’s EndSARS Movement?

When the World Moves On: What’s Next for Nigeria’s EndSARS Movement?

Thursday, December 10, 2020

By: Jonathan Pinckney; Erin Zamora

This week, protesters once again filled the streets of several Nigerian cities as activists called for “Phase II” of the #EndSARS protests that rocked the country in October. While the protesters’ initial grievances focused on police violence by the country’s Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS), many in the movement have since expanded its aims, criticizing government corruption, with some calling for the resignation of President Muhammadu Buhari. While the initial protests seemed to have faded after the army opened fire on peaceful protesters at the Lekki Toll Gate plaza in Lagos, the underlying grievances of the protesters remain unresolved.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Nonviolent Action

Nigeria: Police in Jos Adapt to COVID-Driven Rise in Sexual Violence

Nigeria: Police in Jos Adapt to COVID-Driven Rise in Sexual Violence

Tuesday, December 1, 2020

By: Isioma Kemakolam; Danielle Robertson

Ten months since the coronavirus first emerged, communities around the world still face stay-at-home orders, school closures, and travel restrictions. These policies have led to increased sexual and gender-based violence. While the U.N. secretary-general and heads of state have paid unprecedented attention to this issue, translating political rhetoric into action has proven more difficult. As the pandemic drags on, governments, security actors, and civil society need to rethink how to protect women and girls during lockdowns. While the situation is dire, an opportunity does exist. In Nigeria, where massive protests against police brutality broke out in October, civil society and police are adapting their efforts to address both gender-based violence and the pandemic.

Type: Blog

Gender; Global Health

Protests Test Nigeria’s Democracy and its Leadership in Africa

Protests Test Nigeria’s Democracy and its Leadership in Africa

Thursday, October 22, 2020

By: Oge Onubogu

Nigeria’s protests against police brutality already were the largest in the country’s history before security forces opened fire on a crowd in Lagos on October 20. The protest and bloodshed have only heightened the need for the government in Africa’s most populous country to end the pattern of violence by security forces against civilians. Leaders must finally acknowledge that this brutality has fueled violent extremism. How the Nigerian government will respond to citizens’ insistent demand for accountable governance will influence similar struggles—for democracy, accountability, nonviolence and stability—across much of Africa.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Violent Extremism; Democracy & Governance; Nonviolent Action

View All Publications