In a new volume, “Customary Justice and the Rule of Law in War-Torn Societies” from the United States Institute of Peace, editor Deborah Isser argues that measuring customary justice systems against Western rule-of-law templates leads to strategies that fail to address the concerns of the population and impedes access to justice.

For Immediate Release
Contact: Meg Pierannunzi, 202-429-4736
              Allison Sturma, 202-429-4725

(Washington)– In a new volume, “Customary Justice and the Rule of Law in War-Torn Societies” from the United States Institute of Peace, editor Deborah Isser argues that measuring customary justice systems against Western rule-of-law templates leads to strategies that fail to address the concerns of the population and impedes access to justice.

“Customary justice systems are generally seen as either a side issue on the margins of the justice sector or a troublesome obstacle to the rule of law. The chapters in this volume serve as a sober rebuttal to this view,” said Isser. “The case studies demonstrate that customary justice systems must be treated as an enduring and influential component of the justice landscape as a whole and that policymakers and practitioners who ignore or seek to undermine them are doomed to fail.”

Moving beyond the narrow lens of legal analysis, the seven cases in the volume—Mozambique, Guatemala, East Timor, Afghanistan, Liberia, Iraq, Sudan—incorporate a nuanced analysis of the social, cultural, historical, and institutional context of the justice system as a whole.

Written by experts, the case studies provide advice on how to engage with customary law and suggest concrete ways policymakers can bridge the divide between formal and customary systems in both the short and long term. The recommendations stress the importance of focusing on practical solutions to real and current problems as determined by the population, rather than on pushing for a predetermined end state. The contributors suggest ways to support a constructive and inclusive process through which constituents can create a form of legal pluralism that will best reflect the needs and aspirations of society as a whole.

In conflict-affected communities scarred by legacies of violence, customary justice systems often offer locally legitimate processes for dispute resolution that have a proven capacity to peacefully resolve grievances within the community and prevent the escalation of acute political violence.  The book offers valuable insights for practitioners and policymakers approaching justice and the rule of law in countries like Yemen and Libya that are experiencing political upheaval. The book provides tools so that future engagements do not repeat the mistakes of the past.

Related News

Bipartisan Group of National Security Experts Calls for New Approach to Preventing Extremism

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

News Type: Press Release

Tuesday, February 26, 2019, Washington, DC – A bipartisan group of senior national security experts today made an urgent appeal for the adoption of a new approach to preventing the rise and spread of extremism in the Sahel, Horn of Africa and the Near East. This new approach is set out in the congressionally mandated final report and recommendations of the Task Force on Extremism in Fragile States, hosted by the United States Institute of Peace. The Task Force proposes a comprehensive preventive strategy to stop the spread of extremism that reorganizes U.S. efforts and pools international resources to support partners in fragile states in tackling the drivers of extremism.

Fragility & Resilience

USIP Convenes Inaugural Syria Study Group Meeting

Thursday, February 21, 2019

News Type: Press Release

The United States Institute of Peace (USIP) is pleased to announce it will convene the inaugural meeting of the Congressionally mandated bipartisan Syria Study Group (SSG) on February 28.

National Defense Strategy Commission Releases Its Review of 2018 National Defense Strategy

National Defense Strategy Commission Releases Its Review of 2018 National Defense Strategy

Tuesday, November 13, 2018

News Type: Press Release

The National Defense Strategy Commission (NDSC), a congressionally mandated panel charged with examining and making recommendations with respect to the national defense strategy for the United States and whose work has been facilitated by the United States Institute of Peace, released its final report on November 14, 2018.

Peace Teachers Program Announces 2018 Cohort

Peace Teachers Program Announces 2018 Cohort

Tuesday, July 24, 2018

News Type: Press Release

USIP has chosen Ryan Adams of Chelsea High School in Chelsea, AL; Casandra Bates of Centennial High School in Franklin, TN; JoAnne Bohl of West Central High School in Hartford, SD; and Jennifer O'Boyle of Klahowya Secondary School in Silverdale, WA, to participate in the 2018 Peace Teachers Program. Over the course of the next school year, they will receive training, resources, and support to strengthen their teaching of international conflict management and peacebuilding.

Education & Training

View All News