USIP's Tim Lucarro writes from USIP's field office in Kabul about what some of the city's big homes say about corruption in Afghanistan.

What Kabul's Chic Homes Say About Corruption and Governance
Photo courtesy of NY Times

Each day, the daily commute to USIP’s office in the Wazir Akbar Khan neighborhood of Kabul is punctuated with an unseemly five-minute passage through one of the most horrible sections of the city.

It is not rampant poverty or the scars from the nation’s four generations of war that mar the landscape. Instead it is the opulence and saccharine palaces built by some of Afghanistan’s most notorious warlords, narco-traffickers, and political elite that rise from the frozen streets like twisted gingerbread houses that taint the city. Their presence is a constant reminder of the systemic abuse of power, the inequity of the justice system and endemic corruption that has forged itself into so many areas of the nation since the Taliban’s fall in 2001.

Click here to learn more about USIP's programs in Afghanistan.

Twelve years ago, the Sher Pur area of Kabul was home to tangled blocks of single-story mud homes. These houses had been passed down over generations, often through systems of unregistered and informal titling.

In a nation that has been marked by decades of regime changes, the system of land titling and records of ownership are notoriously convoluted or missing. In 2004, some of the country’s most powerful families and political operatives recognized the expanding value of urban land and they began a systemic campaign to force families from their land and take it as their own. In many instances their actions were considered legal, as all land not formally registered or titled is considered government property – convenient for the government since nearly 75% of all land in Afghanistan is without official title.

Today, Sher Pur is home to some of the most gaudy, poorly-designed homes in all of Kabul. Like most things in town, the styles have been imported from Pakistan and various Gulf states. They are designs meant to be cool during the hot summers of South Asia and the Middle East, but are not built to retain heat well in the high altitude winters of Kabul.

Form over function is their trademark. These homes offer a daily reminder of how a few powerful families and individuals have thrived since 2001, using donor aid, military interventions and perpetually weak governance to their own advantage and to the detriment of Afghanistan’s poorest and most vulnerable. It is a reminder not only to those of us who commute past each day, but to all those who live in Kabul who have born witness to the inequitable growth of a few politically connected families.

Many of those families have ties to former warlords and war criminals who have been allies of NATO forces since 2001. The new bourgeoisie of Afghanistan use their influence within the government to quasi-legally grab land and further entrench their wealth. This happens not just in Sher Pur, but in other sections of the city and throughout the country.

The international community’s support for these leaders and the government system they control is repeatedly cited by the Afghan public as evidence of the international community’s self-interest and indifference to the Afghan people. Whether or not this is true is irrelevant because the perception is real. Partnerships and strategies that were first born of political expediency over a decade ago have led to the long-term de-legitimacy of the state and the international community’s efforts in Afghanistan in the eyes of the general citizenry. The state has come to be seen as serving its own interests, protecting the benefits and windfalls that have been captured by a small elite, at the sacrifice of the genuine protection and support for the rest of the Afghan populace.

Sadly, the daily trip past the houses of Sher Pur, dripping with their external refinement and plastered in a veneer of legitimacy, belies the foundation upon which they have been built. Beside the new mansions, you can see the shattered remains of previous homes, the broken hopes of many Afghans for a government that puts the needs of the people above its own greed.

Click here to read a Q&A with Tim Luccaro about Afghan President Hamid Karzai's call to discuss the U.S.-Afghanistan relationship.

 

Related Publications

Seize This Moment for Afghan Peace Talks

Seize This Moment for Afghan Peace Talks

Monday, May 21, 2018

By: Johnny Walsh

Even though fighting continues, nearly all serious observers believe a political settlement in Afghanistan is the only plausible alternative to open-ended war. So, while Taliban leaders over the last month have announced their annual spring offensive and disputed Kabul and Washington’s sincerity about making peace, they concurrently show signs of flexibility in how they envision a potential peace deal.

Mediation, Negotiation & Dialogue

ISIS Seeks to Threaten Afghan Democracy with Latest Assault

ISIS Seeks to Threaten Afghan Democracy with Latest Assault

Thursday, May 3, 2018

By: USIP Staff; Johnny Walsh

With last week’s attack aimed at discrediting the electoral process and dissuading Afghans from participating, the Islamic State has made clear that it intends to suppress Afghanistan’s democratic development. Afghanistan’s burgeoning independent media is one of the country’s major success stories and most-trusted institutions.

Conflict Analysis & Prevention; Democracy & Governance

Grading Counterterrorism Cooperation with the GCC States

Grading Counterterrorism Cooperation with the GCC States

Thursday, April 26, 2018

By: Leanne Erdberg

This testimony covers the following questions: (1) How have GCC countries addressed violent extremism and terrorism within their own national borders; (2) How have GCC countries addressed violent extremism and terrorism regionally and internationally; and, (3) What recommendations can enable future GCC efforts to go beyond eliminating today’s terrorists and prevent terrorism from emerging in the first place?

Conflict Analysis & Prevention; Civilian-Military Relations; Violent Extremism

Scott Worden on the Taliban in Afghanistan

Scott Worden on the Taliban in Afghanistan

Wednesday, April 25, 2018

By: Scott Worden

Following the horrendous bombing outside a Kabul voter registration center, Scott Worden shares his sobering analysis and commentary about the continuing war in Afghanistan where he says most agree that a military victory is unlikely. The conflicts grinding stalemate, Fall 2018 elections and presidential elections due a year from now concern Worden especially with today’s Taliban announcement of a new fighting season and rejection of President Ghani’s peace offering.

Violent Extremism; Electoral Violence; Conflict Analysis & Prevention

View All Publications