Gulf states have proven to be a dependable port in a storm for China’s oil producers and traders. For the past two decades, the region has consistently supplied China — the world’s largest single crude oil importer — with roughly half of its crude oil imports from overseas. By contrast, it seems China’s oil interests in every other region of the world have been battered by gale force winds.

Oil tankers near the seaport of Ras Tanura in Saudi Arabia., Jan. 11, 2018. (Christophe Viseux/The New York Times)
Oil tankers near the seaport of Ras Tanura in Saudi Arabia., Jan. 11, 2018. (Christophe Viseux/The New York Times)

In Africa, China’s investments in Libya, Sudan, South Sudan and Angola have all faced significant setbacks. In no small part, this has led to a decline in China’s overall crude oil imports from the African continent. As a proportion of China’s global oil imports, African supplies have gone from a high of 31% in 2010 to roughly 15% in 2020 (based on the author’s calculation of data available here).

Similarly, in Venezuela, Iran and Russia, Chinese oil companies have had to navigate international sanctions after expending considerable time and resources in building up collaborations. Western countries are no safer, as China National Offshore Oil Corporation is now said to be reviewing its investments in Canada, the United States and the United Kingdom for fear that its assets could be threatened if relationships with the West deteriorate further.

To complicate matters, China is no fan of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries’ (OPEC) production caps. It is an oil importer with an export economy reliant on manufacturing and has a transport sector that is ravenous for petrol. Although China would not say so publicly, Beijing’s interests are actually aligned with Washington, London and Brussels in having Saudi Arabia’s leadership relax OPEC’s production policy. However, Chinese Communist Party General Secretary Xi Jinping is unlikely to have any more success convincing Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman than Western leaders. Ultimately, there is enormous pressure on Xi to make this relationship work.

Success for Xi?

In light of all this, Xi’s recent visit to the Kingdom appears to have been a success from China’s perspective. Furthermore, China’s leader vowed to buy more Gulf oil and, given China’s oil woes in other regions, there is good reason to believe Gulf oil will only increase in significance in China’s basket of imports.

However, the Gulf states are no panacea for Chinese policymakers. First, the region has its own instabilities. But more importantly, Beijing still needs to safely transport Gulf oil back to China’s eastern seaboard. In recent years China has tried to construct more pipelines to Russia and Central Asia and, in the medium to long run, these pipelines may help address Beijing’s reliance on vulnerable oil tankers traversing sea lanes. But for now, China still has a much bigger headache than other countries who rely on the Middle East for their oil.

As China-bound oil tankers inch across the Indian Ocean, through the Straits of Malacca, and up the South China Sea, flare ups with India, Southeast Asian states, the United States and Australia become a real concern for a country that imports roughly 72% of its crude oil needs from overseas.

Fears of Vulnerability Can Fuel Overreaction

Indeed, if Xi and his Politburo colleagues do have near-term designs on Taiwan, then Beijing may be very concerned about the types of sanctions or blockades that could be placed on China-bound oil tankers.

Seemingly aware of its vulnerabilities, China has taken the opportunity of low Russian prices to increase its commercial and strategic stockpiles of crude oil in recent months. We should also anticipate China’s understandable desire to protect its energy security interests in the longer term.

The calculation from Beijing may be that it has no choice but to increase its security presence in the Indian Ocean and South China Sea. Its challenge will be to do so without inflaming pre-existing tensions or elevating pre-existing fears over China’s putative designs for a network of overseas military bases.

And contrary to the conventional view that China’s security actors are adamant on building new bases imminently, there are still some in Beijing who question the viability of such projects. Not to mention the more important consideration of the agency of the potential host countries, who may be reluctant to host a Chinese base or drive a hard bargain in return for accepting a Chinese naval facility or logistics hub.

There are no easy solutions for Chinese policymakers, but nor are there easy answers for regional powers who are watching China’s energy security requirements producing a Beijing that is overly reliant on Gulf state oil. A jittery Beijing may respond to any perceived threat to China-bound oil tankers with hostile escalation.

In short, a vulnerability for China can become a vulnerability for everyone.


Related Publications

What Does the Emerging China-Africa Minerals Consensus Mean for U.S. Initiatives?

What Does the Emerging China-Africa Minerals Consensus Mean for U.S. Initiatives?

Thursday, September 12, 2024

The recently concluded Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) provided a revealing glimpse into the current state of the Africa-China relationship. On the one hand, the official imagery and language of the summit emphasized constancy — a vision of a stable South-South relationship stretching from the past into the future. On the other hand, the summit also projected a relationship that is being reshaped for a new decade.

Type: Analysis

EconomicsEnvironment

China’s Bid for a Bigger Security Role in Africa

China’s Bid for a Bigger Security Role in Africa

Thursday, September 12, 2024

Last week, China welcomed more than 50 African leaders to Beijing for the ninth Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC), which has met every three years since 2000 to coordinate economic and political relations. FOCAC is China’s main platform for Belt and Road-affiliated projects and Chinese plans for infrastructure development have generally dominated the action plans that come out of the forum. In recent years, exchanges between Chinese and African political parties, legislatures and local governments have also been a focus of the forum. China has also found in FOCAC a source of support for international relations principles it prioritizes, including noninterference and its "one China" principle. While security cooperation has been an element of FOCAC for more than a decade, this year’s forum saw an unprecedented Chinese emphasis on its role in security on the continent.

Type: Analysis

Global Policy

How China Is Leveraging Security Cooperation in Central Asia

How China Is Leveraging Security Cooperation in Central Asia

Monday, September 9, 2024

The July 2024 Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) summit in in Astana, Kazakhstan provided China with another platform to highlight its vision for global governance and security. While the SCO has expanded to include states beyond Central Asia, the organization’s focus on fighting terrorism, separatism and extremism — the so-called “three evils” — is particularly relevant for China in Central Asia, where Beijing looks to test and advance its security cooperation strategies. The SCO, the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and the Global Security Initiative (GSI) are key components of China’s ambition to offer an alternative to what it calls “Western hegemony” and to resist external interference in the domestic affairs of SCO states.

Type: Analysis

Global Policy

At Pacific Islands Forum, Tensions Flare Over Taiwan, Geopolitics and Climate

At Pacific Islands Forum, Tensions Flare Over Taiwan, Geopolitics and Climate

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Last week, the Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) met in Nukuʻalofa, Tonga, to discuss the challenges affecting the region. The PIF is an intergovernmental organization with the purpose of enhancing cooperation among the countries and territories of Oceania, including Australia, New Zealand, 14 independent Pacific Island countries, and France’s territories of New Caledonia and French Polynesia. China and the United States interact with the PIF as dialogue partners and the Pacific Islands have emerged in recent years as another arena of great power competition.

Type: Question and Answer

EnvironmentGlobal Policy

View All Publications