Pakistan is currently experiencing one of the worst environmental disasters in the world. One-third of the country is under water. Over 1,325 people have died and 33 million have been impacted. The latest statistics show that over 1,600 have been injured, 325,000 homes destroyed, 735,000 livestock lost and 2 million acres of crops damaged — numbers which are likely to increase. According to a rough assessment by Atlantic Council’s Uzair Younus and economist Ammar Khan, the direct damage to roads, homes, livestock and crops is over $3 billion, which is an astronomical amount for a developing country like Pakistan.

Rescue boats take displaced people to the area of Thatta, where thousands took refuge, in a small village next to Sujawal, Pakistan, Aug. 30, 2010. (Tyler Hicks/The New York Times)
Rescue boats take displaced people to the area of Thatta, where thousands took refuge, in a small village next to Sujawal, Pakistan, Aug. 30, 2010. (Tyler Hicks/The New York Times)

U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres said, “The Pakistani people are facing a monsoon on steroids — the relentless impact of epochal levels of rain and flooding” as he made a flash $160 million aid appeal for the country. He also issued a dire warning: “Today it is Pakistan, tomorrow it could be your country.” While people are called into action to provide immediate relief, the looming question is: How did this happen?

Pakistan is no stranger to floods or earthquakes or other natural disasters and experiences a monsoon season every year. For some, Pakistan has not invested enough in climate-resilient infrastructure while for others, there is no way that Pakistan could have been prepared for this massive flooding. But the truth lies somewhere in the middle of mismanagement and climate change.

Working Toward Climate Resiliency

Pakistan’s climate challenges are immense. The Global Climate Risk Index 2021 ranked Pakistan as one of the most vulnerable countries in the world to climate change and extreme weather events, despite being one of the lowest carbon emitters in the world. First, the country experienced a record heatwave this spring and now they are flooded within just a few months. In Jacobabad, where temperatures skyrocketed to 50 Celsius/122 Fahrenheit, the city is now submerged.

Many within Pakistan and abroad have used this disaster as the prime example of climate justice, arguing that the Global North should pay reparations for loss and damage claims by the Global South under the Paris Agreement, which was signed in 2015 and currently has 175 signatories, including the European Union. While the Paris Agreement does discuss issues of loss and damages, it is for truly unforeseen issues like climate change-related disasters impacting the agriculture sector, not for every single damage claim.

In the case of Pakistan, one of the main hindrances toward climate resilience is weak governance and cooperation. These factors have led to the proliferation of water mafias, illegal and unregulated construction, and poor urban and rural planning. Under the previous Imran Khan-led Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf government, the country’s climate-resilience efforts focused on tree-planting and the tech sector, specifically related to clean energy, and electric vehicles.

The current Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz and Pakistan Peoples Party coalition government had just taken office when they were faced with an unusual spring heatwave and then the summer monsoons and floods. While it can be argued that planning for a disaster of this magnitude is impossible, on the provincial level there should have been more forethought given to their plans, especially knowing that each year the monsoon rains become more intense.

But this disaster has shown that the majority of the damages that were caused by the flood waters were to structures that never should have been there in the first place. For example, large hotels and entire communities were built alongside rivers — in many cases locations that were impacted by the 2010 floods. Instead of learning the lessons from 2010, these structures were allowed to be built. The fault lies with not just the construction companies or communities, but also with the local governments that did not monitor or regulate this illegal activity.

Expecting More Disasters

The next disaster that Pakistan should be concerned about isn’t next year’s monsoon rains, it is the crises that will follow this year’s floods. Experts anticipate food insecurity, a public health nightmare, massive internal displacement, and the potential for greater migration to already overstretched urban centers.

Climate resiliency will not be possible if industrialized countries do not take responsibility and make changes to combat climate change. The Global North-Global South narrative has put the blame on countries in the Global South for being unable to battle climate change because of corruption. While this isn’t incorrect — corruption is a huge hurdle for any kind of development — this narrative takes the onus off of countries in the Global North when dealing with climate change and its impact around the world. If this false narrative persists, we should be prepared to expect more disasters like the one Pakistan is experiencing now. And if Global North states won’t change their behavior, they can at least shell out aid assistance.

Donor assistance should not just be a blank check in the form of aid dollars, but also collaboration on technical assistance to improve systems to adapt to climate change and mitigate future disasters, which will certainly continue to occur on a more regular basis with greater intensity. To this end, Pakistan also needs to commit to making changes to its systems and policies with respect to disaster planning and management along with climate change. This, however, will require significant political will on the part of the Pakistani state, as these efforts will not be easy fixes.

Sahar Khan is the managing editor of Inkstick Media and a research fellow in the Cato Institute’s Defense and Foreign Policy department.

This article was originally published by Inkstick Media.

Related Publications

A Threshold Alliance: The China-Pakistan Military Relationship

A Threshold Alliance: The China-Pakistan Military Relationship

Wednesday, March 22, 2023

By: Sameer P. Lalwani, Ph.D.

Geopolitical shifts in South Asia over the past decade, driven by sharper US-China competition, a precipitous decline in China-India relations, and the 2021 withdrawal of US forces from Afghanistan, have pushed the Chinese and Pakistani militaries closer together. The countries’ armies and navies are increasingly sharing equipment, engaging in more sophisticated joint exercises, and interacting more closely through staff and officer exchanges. Yet, as this report concludes, a full China-Pakistan alliance is not inevitable, as Chinese missteps and other sources of friction could slow its consummation.

Type: Special Report

Conflict Analysis & Prevention

Rethinking US-Pakistan Relations in the Age of Great Power Competition

Rethinking US-Pakistan Relations in the Age of Great Power Competition

Friday, March 10, 2023

By: Hamza Ijaz;  Imran Khan;  Maryam Kiyani;  Adnan Rafiq

As the United States and Pakistan approach 75 years of bilateral engagement, the relationship between the two countries is at a critical crossroads. While viewing the US-Pakistan relationship exclusively through the security lens seems to be untenable, the road ahead, in the broader context of the Afghanistan withdrawal and great power competition, remains murky. Nevertheless, there exists a willingness on both sides to avoid the lows of the 1990s even if the highs of the 1980s or 2000s are not possible.

Type: Discussion Paper

In Pakistan, Women Police Push for Gender Equality

In Pakistan, Women Police Push for Gender Equality

Thursday, March 9, 2023

By: Amna Kayani;  Jumaina Siddiqui

In Pakistan, few institutions epitomize the connection between power and male dominance better than the police. Even after a decade of Pakistani government efforts to recruit more women in police departments, policing in Pakistan remains an overwhelmingly masculine profession — with women making up less than 3 percent of the country’s police force, despite quotas in place. And for the policewomen who do serve, institutional barriers and societal prejudices have made career progression an increasingly uphill battle.

Type: Blog

GenderJustice, Security & Rule of Law

India and Pakistan Are Playing a Dangerous Game in the Indus Basin

India and Pakistan Are Playing a Dangerous Game in the Indus Basin

Thursday, February 23, 2023

By: Daniel Haines

On January 25, India sent a notice to Pakistan demanding the modification of the Indus Waters Treaty. Pakistan has so far refused to engage. The treaty, which India, Pakistan and the World Bank originally signed in 1960, allocates rights over the waters of several rivers in the Indus Basin to India and Pakistan.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Conflict Analysis & PreventionEnvironment

View All Publications