Truth Commission: Truth and Justice Commission
Duration: 2004 - 2008
Charter: Ley No. 2225
Commissioners: 9
Report: Public report

 

Truth Commission: Truth and Justice Commission (Comisión Verdad y Justicia, CVJ)

Dates of Operation: June 2004 – August 2008 (4 years, 2 months). The commission’s original mandate ended December 2005 but was extended until August 2006 and later until August 2008.

Background: The decades leading up to Alfredo Stroessner's dictatorship were colored by political instability, a civil war, and a war with Bolivia. Stroessner took power in Paraguay from his military, adding to the long history of military rule. Under Stroessner’s 34-year rule, political freedom was limited, dissent was suppressed, the indigenous were assimilated, and the language of the native people was banned from education. The country found itself increasingly isolated from the international community. In February 1989, General André Rodriguez ousted Stroessner from power, and later won the Paraguayan presidential election.

Steps towards stability were taken, including the adoption of a new constitution. Paraguay returned to a civil government in 1993, but political infighting overshadowed the need to address abused of the past. Interest in creating a truth commission heightened when Dr. Martin Almada, a Paraguayan lawyer and human rights activist, accidentally uncovered tons of intelligence documents that exposed the role of Paraguayan security forces in “Operation Condór”. Operation Condór was a covert transnational military network that enabled Chile, Argentina, Uruguay, Bolivia, Paraguay, Brazil, and later Peru and Ecuador to monitor, torture, “disappear” or execute political opponents across borders. The records discovered in Paraguay documented the secret establishment of the network in 1975, the existence of a joint information center at the headquarters of the Chilean secret police in Santiago as well as the involvement of General Stroessner in Operation Condor.

The files discovered in Paraguay became known as the Archive of Terror. The Truth and Justice Commission of Paraguay was established by an act of parliament in October 2003.

Charter: The Paraguayan Congress passed Ley No. 2225 (PDF-11KB) on October 15, 2003.

Mandate:
The CVJ’s mandate is to provide a historical record of abusive practices during the Stroessner dictatorship and to contribute to prosecutions of human rights crimes occurring between 1954 and 1989.

Commissioners and Structure: The CVJ is composed of nine commissioners: eight men and one woman, led by Bishop Monseñor Mario Melanio Medina.

Report: The CVJ’s final report was released on August 28, 2008 and a summary is available in Spanish on the website of the Paraguayan Human Rights Coordinator (CODEHUPY).

Findings:

Conclusions

  • The Commission based its findings on 2,059 testimonies, 14,000 documents and eight public hearings.
  • The Commission reported 19,862 arbitrary detentions, 18,772 cases of torture, at least 59 victims of summary executions, 336 forced disappearances and a total of more than 128,000 victims of the military regime.
  • The commission attributed the systematic violations to the state’s authorities who used the pretext of combating internal subversion, communism and terrorism.
  • The repression was not limited to a specific group but was directed against members of diverse political, social and cultural backgrounds.
  • 7,851,295 hectares (19,400,972 acres) of land were irregularly awarded during the Stroessner regime and the 15 following years of transition, mostly to family members, political and military allies of Stroessner.
  • In April 2006, the commission announced that Alfredo Stroessner was responsible for sixty cases of human rights violations during his regime. Civil society criticized this number to be far too low. Stroessner, at this time in Brazil, was granted the right to defend himself against the accusations.
  • Two months after the release of the final report, a soldier testified to the chairman of the Commission. This testimony revealed the existence of a secret torture chamber in the basement of the former Ministry of the Interior. Political prisoners from Paraguay, Chile, Argentina and Uruguay were probably detained there as part of the Operation Condor.

Recommendations

  • The Commission recommended continuing the search for disappeared individuals.
  • The final report also recommends establishing a center for public information as well as a genetics database.
  • Further, the Commission suggested including the findings of the report in the curriculum of public schools.
  • The Commission recommended a number of cases for formal prosecutions, including several cases on violence against women.

Subsequent Developments:

Reforms

  • In 2005, the UN Human Rights Committee reported that positive changes were made in legislation against gender discrimination, some of which were recommended by the Truth and Justice Commission.
  • The “Archive of Terror”, discovered in 1992, was preserved, and the Archive and Documentation Center for the Defense of Human Rights was created in order to safeguard and to inventory the “Archive of Terror”, the internal records produced by the Paraguayan security forces during the Stroessner regime. This was the first repository of its kind, documenting the work of Operation Condor, discovered in Latin America. (Subsequently, a similar archive was discovered in Guatemala.)

Prosecutions

  • Efforts to prosecute Stroessner failed and he died in exile in August 2006.

Reparations

  • The government initiated a program of reparations, managed by the National Commission on Human Rights. Approximately 400 individuals have received financial compensation so far, totaling $20 million USD.

Special Notes: The lack of resources was a major problem throughout the Commission’s work, especially in its early days when the Paraguayan parliament cut its budget by half. In December 2007, the government stopped the funding of the Commission and it had to suspend investigations for several months.

Sources:

Related Publications

Truth Commission Digital Collection

Truth Commission Digital Collection

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

The United States Institute of Peace’s Truth Commissions Digital Collection is part of the Margarita S. Studemeister Digital Library in International Conflict Management.  The collection contains profiles of truth commissions and substantive bodies of inquiry from nations worldwide - offering general background information on the composition of each body, links to the official legislative texts establishing such commissions, and each commission's final reports and findings.

Conflict Analysis & Prevention; Human Rights

Security and Justice in Post-Revolution Libya

Security and Justice in Post-Revolution Libya

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

By: Fiona Mangan; Christina Murtaugh with support from Ferdaouis Bagga

Three years after the death of Muammar Qaddafi and the end of the revolution in Libya, security and justice are stalled and elusive despite the proliferation of security providers. The power of the gun prevails over the rule of law. Many see no end in sight. Based on a nationwide survey and drawn from interviews and focus group sessions, this report—supported by the USIP and the Small Arms Survey—tracks security and justice in Libya from before the revolution through today, its realities, and...

Justice in Transition in Yemen

Justice in Transition in Yemen

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

By: Erica Gaston with Nadwa al-Dawsari

This research is part of a three-year United States Institute of Peace (USIP) project that explores how Yemen’s rule of law and local justice and security issues have been affected in the post-Arab Spring transition period. A complement to other analytical and thematic pieces, this large-scale mapping provides data on factors influencing justice provision in half of Yemen’s governorates. Its goal is to support more responsive programming and justice sector reform. Field research was managed b...

Civil Defense Groups

Civil Defense Groups

Thursday, July 31, 2014

By: Bruce “Ossie” Oswald

More than three hundred defense groups provide security to local communities in states around the world. While it is true that such groups can be a resource-efficient means for states to provide law and order to their communities, it is also true that they can worsen security.

View All Publications