How is it possible to do community policing in the absence of trust between citizens and security forces? This is just one of the questions that challenged an international group of experts as they explored the role of police and citizens, especially women, in countering violent extremism (CVE), during a workshop hosted by USIP’s Center for Gender and Peacebuilding. 

Nigerian soldiers survey passing civilians in the government reserved area of Maiduguri, in north-eastern Nigeria, July 19, 2011. An Islamist insurgency that has haunted northern Nigeria appears to be branching out and collaborating with al-Qaida's affiliates, alarming Western officials and analysts who had previously viewed the militants here as a largely isolated, if deadly, menace. (Samuel James/The New York Times)
Nigerian soldiers survey passing civilians in the government reserved area of Maiduguri, in north-eastern Nigeria. An Islamist insurgency that has haunted northern Nigeria appears to be branching out. Photo Credit: The NYT/ Samuel James

The workshop grew out of the institute’s Women Preventing Extremist Violence (WPEV) Project, which aims to work with women civic activists in Kenya and Nigeria to foster relationships with police in an effort to build community resilience to violence.

The July 2014 meeting, entitled “Women Preventing Extremist Violence Expert Workshop: Examining the Parameters of Police-Community Engagement in Countering Violent Extremism,” gathered a  mixed group of participants--security sector and gender experts from the United States, civic activists from Kenya and Nigeria, and police from Turkey and the United Kingdom. They defined effective community policing as a partnership between the police and the community to guarantee safety and security for both men and women.

How can communities develop mutually beneficial community policing strategies to reflect the needs of all citizens—men, women, boys and girls?

While community policing is not a new concept, the reality of providing security in transitional areas is complicated by a lack of effective and accountable institutions and basic lack of trust between civilians and the forces that are supposed to protect them. With conditions such as these, how can communities develop mutually beneficial community policing strategies to reflect the needs of all citizens—men, women, boys and girls?

The answer is that there is no one-size-fits-all approach. What emerged from the facilitated discussion, collective brainstorming activities and emblematic case studies was that good community policing is highly dependent on context, must be supported by the community, and is not always done by official police forces.  

The workshop findings provided a foundation for a USIP Special Report. The publication is intended to guide practitioners on developing and designing community policing programs, the role of women in those programs and the implications for CVE strategies.

The experts honed in on the attributes that must exist in a security force for it to be capable of undertaking community policing roles. Unsurprisingly, the experts identified legitimacy, honesty, fairness, transparency, responsiveness and accountability as key characteristics for both the institution as well as the individual members of the force. The workshop participants  also determined that police forces  need to reflect the communities in which they work and hold shared values.

Another key outcome of the discussion was the idea that community policing is not done by the police alone, but that security is a shared responsibility for the police force and its citizens. As a result, a strong relationship based on clear communication between citizens and the police is necessary for a community policing strategy to succeed.

Experts assessed three case studies: one from northern Nigeria, another involving the Somali diaspora in London, and a third from Korogocho in Nairobi, Kenya. Participants mapped the existence of the necessary attributes for effective police-community engagement. Each case had some but not all of the attributes, and the variations among the cases reinforced the importance of context.

In some cases, racial or religious profiling undermined community policing efforts. In other situations, colonial-era policing structures impeded responsiveness to community needs. Policing structures have changed little since Nigeria’s and Kenya’s colonial eras,  when the purpose of the forces was to repress citizens rather than provide them with security.

Each case, however, demonstrated a key requirement that is pivotal to effectiveness: constant and clear communication between the police force and its citizens.

Shannon Zimmerman is a senior program specialist and Megan Loney is a program assistant, both in USIP’s Center for Gender and Peacebuilding. They work on the WPEV project and helped organize and coordinate the expert workshop.

Related Publications

Peace in Nigeria Will Require Accountable Governance

Peace in Nigeria Will Require Accountable Governance

Wednesday, November 6, 2019

By: Oge Onubogu

The security crisis seizing Nigeria these days is kidnappings for ransom. A year ago, the spotlight was on violent conflict between farmers and herders. Before that, it was Boko Haram. Even earlier, it was the tensions in the Niger Delta, and so on. As Nigeria lurches from one violent conflict to another, the country’s leaders and its international supporters become easily—and perhaps understandably—fixated on the latest manifestation of insecurity. The larger problem, however, is that none of this will ever change unless the focus turns more firmly and consistently to the thread that runs through all of that upheaval: the failures of governance.

Type: Blog

Democracy & Governance

As Africa Battles Sexual Violence, a Nigerian City Shows How

As Africa Battles Sexual Violence, a Nigerian City Shows How

Thursday, August 8, 2019

By: Isioma Kemakolam

When civic leaders and officials in Jos, Nigeria, launched an initiative in 2017 to calm repeated bloodshed in the city, a series of dialogue forums with residents revealed a chilling pattern of hidden violence in their midst: sexual assault. Girls and women recounted rapes and attacks for which justice was impossible, often because authorities were unresponsive. The women faced a problem common to their sisters across Africa: national laws against sexual violence were having little effect on the ground. But the dialogues have wrought a change. In May, police in Jos opened the city’s first unit dedicated to investigating sexual and gender crimes.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Justice, Security & Rule of Law

The Current Situation in Nigeria

The Current Situation in Nigeria

Saturday, June 1, 2019

As Africa’s most populous country, largest economy, and biggest democracy, Nigeria is a bellwether for the continent. National and state elections in 2019 were deeply competitive, with scattered instances of violence amid a mostly peaceful process. However, historically low voter turnout signals a deepening distrust in government and institutions. Overall, Nigeria has made major strides in its democratic development, but still has significant work to do in improving national, state, and local governance.

Type: Factsheet

Amid Rising Sahel Violence, Burkina Faso Builds a Response

Amid Rising Sahel Violence, Burkina Faso Builds a Response

Thursday, May 16, 2019

By: James Rupert

A perfect storm of violence is breaking upon Africa’s Sahel. Since late 2018, communal conflicts—many over access to food, water or productive land—have produced thousands of deadly attacks. Across the region, nearly 4,800 people died in conflicts from November to March, according to the violence-monitoring group ACLED. The greatest surge in bloodshed is in Burkina Faso, where communal militias or religious extremists killed 500 people over five months. But amid the dire headlines, governments and civic groups in Burkina Faso and other Sahel countries cite progress in stabilizing communities with a basic step that simply has seldom been undertaken: broad, local dialogues among community groups, police forces and officials. Community leaders and government officials say they are now expanding those dialogues to improve national security policies to help counter the tide of violence.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Fragility & Resilience; Justice, Security & Rule of Law

View All Publications