We are in one of the largest waves of nonviolent resistance in history. Even the COVID-19 pandemic could not stop massive uprisings in Thailand, Belarus, Myanmar and elsewhere as ordinary citizens use nonviolent tactics to challenge entrenched authoritarians and demand reform. Yet, even as more and more people have hit the streets to push for change, the Varieties of Democracy project reports that global democracy has never been weaker and the long trend of growing autocracy has only accelerated. What can be done to turn this around?

Anti-government protesters gather in Bangkok, Nov. 19, 2010. (Agnes Dherbeys/International Herald Tribune)
Anti-government protesters gather in Bangkok, Nov. 19, 2010. (Agnes Dherbeys/International Herald Tribune)

My new research, which I’ll discuss in a webinar hosted by the International Center for Nonviolent Conflict (ICNC) on April 14, and that has just been published in an ICNC special report, shows that one key factor in leading from authoritarianism to democracy is the mechanism through which civil resistance campaigns achieve their key breakthroughs. The breakthrough mechanism shapes the political environment of the transition, which in turn has long-term consequences for the country’s future politics.

Campaigns that achieve breakthrough via elections or negotiations — mechanisms that give civil resistance campaigns momentum at the beginning of a transition — tilt the balance of power in their favor. These breakthrough mechanisms begin to set up new political institutions that tend to lead to greater democracy, while those that rely on old regime elites or that break down political institutions foreshadow a return to authoritarianism.

Supporting Evidence

How do these breakthroughs occur? Looking at 76 maximalist campaigns that achieved their stated goals from 1945 to 2011, I found that these campaigns brought about one of six types of breakthroughs:

  1. An election
  2. A negotiation process with their main opponents
  3. The resignation of the head of state
  4. A coup d’état by regime insiders
  5. An external intervention
  6. An overwhelming in which resistance becomes so widespread that the opponent’s ability to fight back simply disintegrates

Out of these six ways of achieving a breakthrough, I suspected that elections and negotiations would best set up the kind of political transition that tends to lead to democracy. The numbers bear that suspicion out. While no breakthrough mechanism is a guarantee of future democracy, countries in which civil resistance campaigns achieved political breakthrough via elections or negotiations had significantly higher levels of democracy five years afterwards. This was true even when accounting for contextual factors that tend to promote democracy, like a country’s level of economic development or political history.

The 2018 “Velvet Revolution” in Armenia provides some detail on why civil resistance-induced negotiations and elections favor democratization. After years of youth-led activism, the political opposition in Armenia organized a civil resistance campaign demanding the ouster of long-time authoritarian president (later prime minister) Serzh Sargsyan. The campaign succeeded shockingly quickly, after violent state repression against them backfired. Their key breakthrough moment came when, under pressure from the protesters outside and despite still being dominated by Sargsyan loyalists, the Armenian parliament voted opposition leader Nikol Pashinyan in as Armenia’s new prime minister.

Achieving breakthrough via an election set the Armenian transition on a powerful democratizing path, as it empowered both opposition and civil society actors to shape the trajectory of political reform while also giving the new government significant institutional legitimacy. The result has been a sharp increase in Armenia’s level of democracy, a comprehensive campaign against corruption, and a revitalized civil society.

There is still much more democratization to be done in Armenia. Many of these gains were threatened by the political fallout from Armenia’s 2020 armed conflict with Azerbaijan, in which the opposition (and the Armenian military) initially demanded Prime Minister Pashinyan’s resignation. Yet so far the new government has been able to weather these challenges, and successfully negotiated a deal with the opposition to resolve the crisis by organizing early elections.

On the Other Hand

Breakthrough mechanisms are certainly not the only thing that matters in shaping the path from civil resistance to democracy. As I’ve shown in prior research, the characteristics of the post-breakthrough transition — in particular how much civic mobilization and a continued street presence with maximalist demands and disruptive actions driving transitional politics — have a major impact on future democracy. And a country’s history, economy and geopolitical environment shape how these dynamics play out. But breakthrough mechanisms provide a key moment of leverage in which activists and political leaders can shape the future trajectory of their countries.

Takeaways

So, what can activists and their allies do to help make pro-democracy breakthroughs more likely? As recent ICNC research from Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan shows, training and education are among the most powerful means of supporting nonviolent action. Many grassroots movements, particularly those that are more spontaneous or rely on a “leaderless” organizational model, struggle to engage with institutional avenues of politics like elections. Many also struggle to meaningfully integrate nonviolent action with dialogue and negotiation. Building this capacity in movements before breakthrough occurs can help position movements to better take advantage of opportunities that arise with democratizing breakthroughs.

The U.S. Institute of Peace has developed several key resources that can help movements hone these skills, particularly in combining nonviolent action with negotiation to achieve a positive breakthrough. These and other educational resources can help movements strategize how to set up their tactics for a democratizing breakthrough.

As autocracy rises, the stakes of effectively deploying civil resistance could not be higher. Now more than ever, it is crucial that civil resistance campaigns not just win, but win well.

This article was originally published on the International Center for Nonviolent Conflict’s “Minds of the Movement” blog.

Related Publications

Digital Authoritarianism and Nonviolent Action: Challenging the Digital Counterrevolution

Digital Authoritarianism and Nonviolent Action: Challenging the Digital Counterrevolution

Tuesday, July 27, 2021

By: Matthew Cebul; Jonathan Pinckney

Nonviolent action campaigns are one of the most common ways citizens seek to peacefully change nonresponsive political systems. Yet recently developed and emergent technologies are transforming the nature of interactions between activists and authoritarian governments. This report examines the increasingly sophisticated set of tools—such as facial recognition and surveillance of social media platforms—authoritarian regimes are using to stifle nonviolent movements, and provides recommendations for how policymakers and activists can develop creative strategies for overcoming digital authoritarianism.

Type: Special Report

Nonviolent Action

Building a Peaceful Africa Through Arts, Culture and Heritage

Building a Peaceful Africa Through Arts, Culture and Heritage

Monday, July 26, 2021

By: Makila James

Across the continent, Africans are increasingly using the arts to reimagine their world and reclaim public space to reflect on what a more peaceful and prosperous Africa could look like. Indeed, the African Union (AU) has prioritized art for only the second time in its history with its 2021 theme, “Arts, Culture and Heritage: Levers for Building the Africa We Want.” Leaders are hopeful that by channeling this surge in artistic expression, they can help create conditions to deliver peace to conflict-prone regions of the continent and implement the goals of the AU’s Agenda 2063 and the U.N. Sustainable Development Goals.

Type: Blog

Nonviolent Action

How—and When—People Power Can Advance Peace Amid Civil War

How—and When—People Power Can Advance Peace Amid Civil War

Thursday, July 15, 2021

By: Luke Abbs; Marina G. Petrova

Despite a brief lull due to COVID-19 restrictions, the past few years have witnessed one of the largest waves of global nonviolent resistance in recent history, with 2019 widely being dubbed “the year of the protest.” These movements — from Myanmar to Colombia to India — are largely focused on pushing back against authoritarianism or redressing social injustices. Less heralded and discussed is the role of nonviolent action amid civil wars and peace processes. Strategic nonviolence can foster peace in these contexts as well — but the timing and tactics are key to success.

Type: Analysis and Commentary

Nonviolent Action

SNAP: Synergizing Nonviolent Action and Peacebuilding (Burmese)

SNAP: Synergizing Nonviolent Action and Peacebuilding (Burmese)

Wednesday, June 30, 2021

By: Nadine Bloch; Lisa Schirch

ဤလမ်းညွှန်စာအုပ်သည် ပဋိပက္ခ အသွင်ပြောင်းလဲခြင်း သို့ ဦးတည်ရာတွင်နည်းလမ်းများအား မဟာဗျူဟာကျကျ ထိထိရောက်ရောက် အသုံးပြုနိုင် စေရန်ငြိမ်းချမ်းရေး တည်ဆောက်သူများ နှင့် အကြမ်းမဖက်လှုပ်ရှားမှု ဖော်ဆောင်သူများ အကြား ချိတ်ဆက်ရန် ကြိုးပမ်းခြင်းဖြစ်သည်။ ၎င်းသည် တရားမျှတမှုနှင့် ရေရှည်တည်မြဲသော ငြိမ်းချမ်းရေးကိုမြှင့်တင်ရန်အ ပြန်အလှန်ပြောဆိုခြင်း၊ တိုက်ရိုက်လုပ်ဆောင်မှုများ နှင့် နည်းလမ်းများကို ပေါင်းစပ် အသုံးချနိုင်ကြောင်း ပြသခြင်းဖြစ်သည်။ ဤလမ်းညွှန်စာအုပ်သည် ၎င်းတို့၏လုပ်ငန်းခွင်တွင် အကြမ်းမဖက် လှုပ်ရှားမှုနှင့် ငြိမ်းချမ်းရေး တည်ဆောက်ခြင်း နည်းလမ်းများအား မည်သို့ ပေါင်းစပ်အသုံးပြုရမည်ကို လေ့လာလိုသည့် စီစဉ်သူများ ၊ စည်းရုံးရေးမှူးများ၊ တက်ကြွလှုပ်ရှားသူများ ၊ ကြားဝင် ဖျန်ဖြေသူများ၊ ကြားဝင် ညှိနှိုင်းသူများ နှင့် ငြိမ်းချမ်းရေးတည်ဆောက်သူများအား ပံ့ပိုးပေးနေသော သင်တန်းဆရာများ ၊ ပံ့ပိုးပေးသူများ နှင့် အခြားလက်တွေ့ ကျင့်သုံးသူများအတွက်ဖြစ်သည်။

Type: Toolkit

Nonviolent Action

View All Publications