Home
United States Institute of Peace
logo
SitemapSearch
Virtual Diplomacy Homepage >> Virtual Diplomacy Publications >> Networking Dissent

Released Online
8 November 1999

CONTENTS

Introduction

PART ONE
Technology, Internet Activism and the Crisis in Burma

Technological Revolution and Internet Activism

The Standoff in Burma

A Short History of how the Internet Came to Play a Role in the Burma Crisis

PART TWO
Case Studies

The Massachusetts Selective Purchasing Legislation

The Free Burma Coalition and the Pepsi Boycott Campaign

The Pepsi Campaign at Harvard University

The Network

Assessing the Results

PART THREE
The Internet's Impact on Activism

Advantages of Using the Internet

Disadvantages of Using the Internet

Conclusion

APPENDICES

Appendix A: The Internet Activist Survey Results

Appendix B: Sample Survey

Appendix C: Selected Internet Resources on Burma

Appendix D: Selected Electronic Mail Messages

Footnotes

Virtual Diplomacy Initiative Reports Banner

 

Networking Dissent
Cyber-Activists Use the Internet to Promote Democracy in Burma

Tiffany Danitz and Warren P. Strobel

Footnotes

1. See Appendix C.  return

2. Dana Priest, "U.S. Activist Receives Nobel Peace Prize for Land Mine Campaign; Home-Based Effort, via Computer, led to International Ban in Treaty," The Washington Post, October 11, 1997, p. A1. return

3. See, for example, Warren P. Strobel, Late-Breaking Foreign Policy: The News Media’s Impact on Peace Operations (Washington, DC: U.S. Institute of Peace Press, 1997). return

4. For example, see Brook Larmer, Revolutions Without Guns: Nonviolent Resistance in the "Global Village," unpublished work-in-progress presentation, U.S. Institute of Peace, April 27, 1995. return

5. Ibid.; Ted Koppel, "The Global Information Revolution and TV News," address to the United States Institute of Peace conference, Managing Chaos, Washington, DC, December 1, 1994; Johanna Neuman, The Media: Partners in the Revolutions of 1989, Atlantic Council Occasional Paper (Washington, DC: Atlantic Council Publications, June 1991). return

6. Secretary of State George Shultz, quoted in David Ronfeldt, "Cyberocracy Is Coming," The Information Society Journal, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 243-296. Also at www.livelinks.com/sumeria/politics/cyber.html. return

7. Johanna Neuman, Lights, Camera, War (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1996), p. 255.return

8. See, for example, Marshall McLuhan and Quentin Fiore, The Medium Is the Message (New York: Random House, 1967). return

9. Jacques Ellul, The Technological Bluff (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1990), p. 76, quoted in Ronfeldt, "Cyberocracy Is Coming." return

10. Ronfeldt, "Cyberocracy Is Coming." return

11. See, for example, Stephen Bates, The Potential Downside of the National Information Infrastructure (Washington, DC: The Annenberg Washington Program, 1995). return

12. Ronfeldt explores this concern in depth in "Cyberocracy Is Coming." return

13. Graeme Browning, Electronic Democracy: Using the Internet to Influence American Politics (Wilton, CT: Pemberton Press, 1996); Ronfeldt, "Cyberocracy Is Coming." return

14. Quoted in T.T. Nhu, "Internet Bolsters Burma Boycott Web Clout: On line networking helps unite pro-democracy efforts," San Jose Mercury News, January 6, 1997. return

15. The World Book Encyclopedia 1988 Edition, Vol. 2 (Chicago: World Book Inc., 1987), p. 719. return

16. Ibid., pp. 722-23. return

17. Interview with Tin Maung Win, editor of New Era Journal, Washington, 1995. return

18. State Department 1997 Country Report on Human Rights Practices. return

19. Ibid.return

20. U.S. Department of State, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988 (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1989). return

21. Ibid., Interview with Tin Maung Win. return

22. SLORC declaration No. 1/88 published in the official Working People's Daily, Rangoon, September 23, 1988. return

23. State Department 1997 Country Report on Human Rights Practices. return

24. March 7, 1997, letter from Sen. Mitch McConnell to Secretary of State Madeleine Albright (United States Senate, Committee on Appropriations). return

25. Tiffany Danitz, "China Trades Arms to Burma for Heroin," Insight, March 24, 1997, p. 12. return

26. Various interviews, electronic correspondence with Coban Tun. return

27. Interview with Douglas Steele, Washington, DC, February 2, 1997; A. Lin Neumann, "The Resistance Network," Wired, vol. 4.01, p. 108. return

28. Ibid. return

29. Neumann, "The Resistance Network"; Communicators of Conscience: Humanitarian and Human Rights Organizations’ Use of the Internet (New York: The Freedom Forum Media Studies Center, 1994), Martha FitzSimmon, ed., p. 25. return

30.  Steele interview. return

31. The BurmaNet News, No. 603, January 3, 1997. The full text of BurmaNet’s daily news reports are archived at: ftp://Sunsite.unc.edu/pub/academic/political-science/freeburma/bnn/return

32. Steele interview. Interview with Michael Beer, Washington, DC, December 19, 1996. See also, The Associated Press, "Asian Rebels Use Internet," The (Annapolis) Sunday Capital, April 23, 1995, p. A12. return

33. BurmaNet Editor, "The Free Burma Movement and the Internet," unpublished manuscript. The writer, while known to the authors, requested anonymity. return

34. Ibid. Beer interview. See also, Barbara Crossette, "Burmese Opposition Gets Oslo Radio Service," The New York Times, July 19, 1992, p. 11. return

35. Information provided by Mike Mitchell, International Republican Institute. return

36. December 15, 1996, e-mail message posted on BurmaNet. return

37. June 28, 1997, e-mail message posted on BurmaNet. return

38. Interview with Beer; authors’ monitoring of BurmaNet and related electronic mail lists. return

39. Posting in The BurmaNet News, No. 762, July 1, 1997. return

40. This was contained in an e-mail welcome message after one of the authors electronically subscribed to MyanmarNet. return

41.  Steele interview. return

42. Various e-mail messages. return

43. Gov. William Weld, remarks at Burma bill signing, June 25, 1996. Provided by the governor’s office. return

44. See, for example, Theo Emery, "Motorola, HP to Cut Ties to Burma: Cite Massachusetts Law Barring Business in Nation," The Boston Globe, November 29, 1996, p. B11. return

45. See, for example, "A State’s Foreign Policy: The Mass That Roared," The Economist, February 8, 1997, pp. 32-33. return

46. As of January 1999. Note: List is meant to be suggestive; other localities also may have passed such legislation. >return

47. Interview with Rep. Byron Rushing, Boston, January 23, 1997. return

48. Interview with Jose Juves, Boston, January 23, 1997. return

49. Juves, Rushing interviews. return

50. Interview with Simon Billenness, January 23, 1997.  return

51. See Appendix C. return

52. Rushing interview. return

53. See Wayne Woodlief, "Burma Bill May Gain Votes for Weld," The Boston Herald, June 13, 1996, p. 35; Michael Kranish, "Proposed Sanctions on Burma a Hot Issue for Weld, Kerry," The Boston Globe, June 14, 1996. return

54. Copies of letters provided by Gov. Weld’s office. return

55. Juves interview. This would be consistent with others’ findings about the impact of media and communication technology on decision makers, namely, that its chief effects are to push issues to the top of the agenda and accelerate decision making. See Strobel, Late-Breaking Foreign Policy, and Martin Linsky, Impact: How the Press Affects Federal Policymaking (New York: W.W. Norton, 1986). return

56. Juves interview. return

57. Ibid. return

58. One count found twenty-seven state, county and city sanctions dealing with Burma, Nigeria, Cuba and Tibet. See Michael S. Lelyveld, "Massachusetts Sanctions Struck Down: Judge’s Ruling May Set Precedent for State Bans," Journal of Commerce, November 6, 1998. For skeptical views of these developments, see "The Mass That Roared," and David R. Schmahmann and James S. Finch, State and Local Sanctions Fail Constitutional Test, Trade Policy Briefing Paper No. 3 (Washington, DC: The Cato Institute, August 6, 1998). return

59. Lelyveld, "Massachusetts Sanctions Struck Down." See also Appendix C, E-mail No. 3. return

60. "L.A. Bans Trade Ties to Burma Despite Federal Ruling," Inter Press Service, Washington, DC, December 17, 1998. return

61. Neumann, "The Resistance Network." return

62. Interview with Billenness, 1997. return

63. Juves interview. return

64. Interview with student activist Marco Simons, Boston, January 24, 1997. return

65. For a fascinating example of how individuals using the Internet can affect investment policy, see Appendix C. return

66. Telephone interview with Reed Cooper, Washington, DC, March 1995. return

67. Michael Hirsh and Ron Moreau, "Making It in Mandalay," Newsweek, June 19, 1995, p. 24. return

68. Press release by The Seattle Campaign for a Free Burma, April 24, 1995. Also in Resolution 29077. return

69. Ibid. return

70. Billenness interview. return

71. Quoted in Neumann, "The Resistance Network." return

72. This section is based on interviews with Marco Simons in Boston, January 1997, and Zar Ni in Washington, DC, in February 1997. return

73. Simons, Billenness interviews. return

74. Simons interview. return

75. Selective purchasing laws were being considered across the country by local city councils. return

76. Simons interview. return

77. Constructive engagement is the free-market argument for investment in troubled regions. The argument goes that with investment, the standard of living is raised for the average person. This in turn raises the expectations for rights and freedoms from the government. At the same time the heightened economy requires a free flow of information, which boils down to technology and freedoms of press and speech. These then open up a previously closed society. return

78. In Burma, the currency is virtually worthless, so foreign investors have to repatriate their profits before taking them out of the country. The human rights community firmly believed that PepsiCo was buying agricultural goods to sell to recoup their profits and that those goods were harvested with state-enforced slave labor. Macy’s department stores had published a similar list, and the resulting pressure proved destructive to their investment. return

79. The many such articles include a front-page report by Joe Urschel, "College Cry: ‘Free Burma’ Activists Make Inroads with U.S. Companies," USA Today, April 29, 1996, p. 1A. return

80. Steele interview. return

81. Simons interview. return

82. Ibid. return

83. Tiffany Danitz, "Burmese Junta Says U.S. a Partner in Terrorism," The Washington Times, July 4, 1997. p. A9. return

84. William Barnes, "Generals Fight Back Through Internet," South China Morning Post, March 19, 1997. return

85. See BurmaNet Editor, The Free Burma Movement and the Internetreturn

86. Ibid.; Billenness, Beer interviews. return

87. BurmaNet Editor, The Free Burma Movement and the Internet. return

88. Larmer, Revolutions Without Guns, p. 9. return

89. Rajiv Chandrasekaran and Elizabeth Corcoran, "Human Errors Block E-Mail, Web Sites in Internet Failure: Garbled Address Files from Va. Firm Blamed," The Washington Post, July 18, 1997, p. A1. return

90. See The BurmaNet News, No. 701, April 23, 1997. return

91. Simons interview. return

92. Electronic mail message on BurmaNet, dated May 27, 1997. return

93. Information provided by Mike Mitchell, IRI. return

94. The Free Burma Movement and the Internet.  return

95. See Appendix C. return

96. Zar Ni, "How to Read Burma and Burma Reports," e-mail posted on free-burma listserv, January 10, 1997. return

97. U Ne Oo, "The Grassroots Activism and Internet," article posted on BurmaNet, May 16, 1997. return

98. For example, see Browning, Electronic Democracy, pp. 79-81. return

99. Rushing interview. return

100. The Free Burma Movement and the Internet. return

101. Ibid. For more on this problem in U.S. society, see Browning, Electronic Democracy, pp. 76-79. return

102. Beer interview. return

103. Rushing interview. return

104. The Free Burma Movement and the Internet.
return

105. Larmer, Revolution Without Guns, pp. 18-20. return

106. See Footnote 31. return

107. The total comes to more than thirty-three because several respondents reported more than one Internet account. return

* As of December 1998. return

108. Taken from the Free Burma Digest, transmitted January 27, 1997. return

109. Massachusetts Burma Roundtable, ACTION ALERT: March 8, 1996 return

110. Transmitted by Simon Billenness to free-burma listserv, February 11, 1997. return

111. Transmitted to free-burma listserv, January 6, 1997. return

112. E-mail posted by Okkar on BurmaNet listserv, February 27, 1997. return

Back to Contents


Home  |  Jobs  |  FAQs   |  Contact Us  |  Directions  |  Privacy Policy  |  Site Map


United States Institute of Peace  --  1200 17th Street NW  -- Washington, DC 20036
(202) 457-1700 (phone)  --  (202) 429-6063 (fax)
Send Feedback