Programs to strengthen the role of women in transitional countries must focus not only on helping women build necessary technical skills but also on targeting decision-makers who can support women’s participation. Those are the conclusions from a meeting of international organizations working in locations such as Yemen, Nigeria, Sudan and South Sudan.

20130106-SUDAN_OUTLOOK_2-TOB.jpg
Photo Credit: NY Times

The groups gathered to discuss effective evaluation approaches and methodologies of programs to advance women’s “empowerment” and what key lessons have been learned over the years. USIP is now applying those lessons in designing an evaluation of two such programs supported by the office of the U.S. Special Envoy for Sudan and South Sudan.

USIP, which adopted a new evaluation policy last year, organized the workshop on Oct. 22, 2013, with experts from the special envoy’s office, Oxfam - Great Britain, the Institute for Inclusive Security, the National Democratic Institute, the Alliance for Peacebuilding, Partners for Democratic Change, and Search for Common Ground. The main findings of the session dealt with designing programs, clarifying the purposes of evaluations for either learning or accountability, defining success, and identifying mechanisms for improving evaluation methods.

On the issue of how to design effective programming, participants largely found that most projects were focused on practical skills women need to engage in social, economic, and political life, such as training in advocacy and leadership and in creating strong, self-sustaining networks. The theory has been that these kinds of skills will underpin their ability to advance gender-related concerns.

Yet, as discussed during the workshop, training and coaching for these capabilities, while necessary, isn’t sufficient. In many cases, it has limited impact on women’s lower status in the society. Programs need to not only target the disempowered but also those in powerful positions. It is critical to engage  key institutional processes that affect those dynamics, including the legislative and judicial systems. This means that women’s capacity-building programs should also incorporate men into their activities. Such engagement may allay distrust among men, and in turn encourage them to become proponents of the program’s objectives.

Programs also need be designed in a way that brings women participants into direct contact with key social, economic and political players and institutions to help influence change. These lessons parallel a shift in terminology from “empowerment” to concepts of inclusivity and leadership development. Participants in the workshop made clear that “empowerment” was not an end in itself, but rather a means toward a broader goal, whether that is a more inclusive peace or more equitable political participation.

Workshop participants also took an in depth look at the purpose of evaluations, noting the tendency to focus on meeting stated objectives that often are defined by the need to justify activities to donors. This emphasis on accountability, however, has often precluded evaluations from serving as a tool for learning, to make programs more effective.

Participants noted that donors often commissioned evaluations to show simply whether the program worked or not, instead of examining why it worked or allowing for mid-program adjustments and improvements. Ideally an evaluation would do all of these, but different methodologies often only allow for one or the other. Striking a better balance should be a priority for implementing organizations and the donor community alike.  

Another challenge of evaluating the effectiveness of programs for women is how to define success. Expectations need to be realistic, as often those countries where such programs are being implemented offer limited opportunities for women to play an active role in social, economic, and political life. Incremental and subtle social changes, even as basic as women feeling independent enough to make friends without prior approval of their husbands, need to be appreciated and recognized as achievements in their own right. Without such incremental changes, the larger institutional and social changes that such programs ultimately aspire to achieve cannot be accomplished.

The importance of project monitoring was also a focus of the workshop. Participants noted that evaluations often are only as effective as the monitoring that goes into them. Process and outcome indicators can give key insight and are important to track, along with standard outputs. In other words, the monitoring of the program should look beyond the bare data such as numbers of trainees, workshops held, etc., and should seek to answer if and how tangible changes in the lives of women actually took place.

The bottom line is to design monitoring and evaluation so that it goes beyond skills and basic accountability for specific objectives and adds substantively to knowledge on how to improve existing and future programs. USIP’s evaluation of two cross-border programs for the special envoy’s office will be geared not only to assessing those specific projects but also to learning from them for similar endeavors going forward.

Osama Gharizi is USIP’s program officer for learning and evaluation. For more information please contact him at ogharizi@usip.org.

Related Publications

The Latest @ USIP: How Civil Society is Addressing Haiti’s Crisis

The Latest @ USIP: How Civil Society is Addressing Haiti’s Crisis

Monday, March 25, 2024

By: Dr. Marie-Marcelle Deschamps

In the past few years, life in Haiti has been dominated by gangs’ growing control over huge swathes of the capital, Port-au-Prince. For Haitian families, this crisis has meant extreme violence, pervasive unemployment, lack of education for children and reduced access to health care. 2023 Women Building Peace Award finalist Dr. Marie-Marcelle Deschamps serves as the deputy executive director, the head of the women's health program and the manager of the clinical research unit of GHESKIO Centers in Port-au-Prince. She spoke to USIP about how her work helps women and their families, and what the global community can do to help Haitian civil society address this devastating humanitarian crisis.

Type: Blog

Conflict Analysis & PreventionGender

Addressing Gendered Violence in Papua New Guinea: Opportunities and Options

Addressing Gendered Violence in Papua New Guinea: Opportunities and Options

Thursday, March 7, 2024

By: Negar Ashtari Abay, Ph.D.;  Kathleen Kuehnast, Ph.D.;  Gordon Peake, Ph.D.;  Melissa Demian, Ph.D.

Each year, more than 1.5 million women and girls in Papua New Guinea experience gender-based violence tied to intercommunal conflict, political intimidation, domestic abuse, and other causes. It is, according to a 2023 Human Rights Watch report, “one of the most dangerous places to be a woman or girl.” Bleak as this may seem, it is not hopeless. USIP’s new report identifies several promising approaches for peacebuilding programming to reduce gender-based violence and effect meaningful and lasting change in Papua New Guinea.

Type: Special Report

Gender

The Challenges Facing Afghans with Disabilities

The Challenges Facing Afghans with Disabilities

Thursday, February 29, 2024

By: Belquis Ahmadi

In Afghanistan, obtaining accurate data on the number of persons with disabilities — including gender-disaggregated information — has always been a challenging endeavor. But based on the data we do have, it’s clear that more than four decades of violent conflict have left a considerable portion of the Afghan population grappling with various forms of disabilities, both war-related and otherwise. And the pervasive lack of protective mechanisms, social awareness and empathy surrounding disability continue to pose formidable challenges for individuals with disabilities, with women being disproportionately affected.

Type: Analysis

GenderHuman Rights

The Latest @ USIP: Children Born of War

The Latest @ USIP: Children Born of War

Tuesday, February 27, 2024

By: Eunice Otuko Apio

Unfortunately, children born as a result of conflict-related sexual violence have been overlooked in the international community’s peacebuilding agenda for a long time. Eunice Otuko Apio, a member of Uganda's Parliament and a finalist for USIP’s 2022 Women Building Peace Award, discusses why children born of war have historically been marginalized in peace processes, how resources can be used to support them and their families more effectively, and how women can contribute to peacebuilding more broadly.

Type: Blog

GenderHuman Rights

View All Publications